Section Explanation
Status.
The status indicator provides an assessment of the overall quality and
maturity of the technology description. One of four indicators is assigned
by the STR staff:
Draft, In Review, Advanced, or Complete.
Draft technology descriptions have the following attributes:
- They need more work.
- They have generally not been reviewed.
- Overall assessment: While technology descriptions labeled "Draft" will
contain some useful information, readers should not rely on these descriptions
as their only source of information about the topic. Readers should consider
these descriptions as starting points for conducting their own research about
the technology.
In Review technology descriptions have the following attributes:
- They are thought to be in fair technical shape.
- They have begun an internal review cycle1.
- They may have major issues that must be resolved, or some sections that may
require additional text.
- Relevant keywords have been added to the Keyword Index.
- Overall assessment: Readers can get some quality information from these,
but because these descriptions have not been completely reviewed, readers
should explore some of the references for additional information and consider
conducting their own research about the technology.
Advanced technology descriptions have the following attributes:
- They are in good technical shape.
- Internal review has occurred.
- There are minor issues to be worked, but it is generally polished.
- They are subject to additional review by external reviewers.
- Relevant keywords have been added to the Keyword Index.
- Overall assessment: These descriptions are in rather good shape, but
because they have not been through external review, readers should exercise
some caution.
- Note: We encourage readers to critique Advanced technology
descriptions, especially for content accuracy. Please see the
feedback section
for more details.
Complete technology descriptions have the following attributes:
- At least one expert external review has occurred, and issues from that
review have been resolved.
- Relevant keywords have been added to the Keyword Index.
- No additional work is necessary at this time.
- Overall assessment: These technology descriptions are believed to be
complete and correct. They would be revised in the future based on additional
external reviewers, new information, and public feedback.
- Note: We encourage readers to critique Complete technology descriptions,
especially for content accuracy. Please see the
feedback
section for more details.
1
Internal review cycle refers to the review process that takes place within the
development/editorial team.