Patterns of Failure: System Archetypes

Ten systems archetypes describe common patterns of behavior across all organizations. The SEI has undertaken an exploration of these archetypes as part of a continuing effort to identify and resolve patterns of failure in acquisition.

The systems archetypes are a set of general, recurring, systems-thinking patterns. These patterns have been found to have broad applicability across many different kinds of systems, including acquisition processes, as their descriptions reveal:

  • Fixes that Fail—A quick fix that produces immediate positive results, but its unforeseen long-term consequences worsen the problem.
  • Balancing Loop With Delay—The current state of a system is moved toward the desired state though repeated actions, but the delay raises doubts about their effectiveness.
  • Shifting the Burden ("Addiction")—An expedient solution temporarily solves a problem, but its repeated use makes it harder to employ a more fundamental solution.
  • Accidental Adversaries—Two parties destroy their relationship through escalating retaliations for perceived injuries.
  • Escalation—Two parties compete for superiority, with each escalating its actions to get ahead.
  • Drifting Goals—A gradual decline in performance or quality goals goes unnoticed, threatening the long-term future of the system.
  • Growth and Underinvestment—Investments in a growing area aren't made, so growth stalls, which then rationalizes further underinvestment.
  • Success to the Successful—When two parties compete for a limited resource, the initially more successful party receives more resources, increasing its success.
  • Limits to Growth—Initially rapid growth slows because of an inherent capacity limit in the system that worsens with growth.
  • Tragedy of the Commons—A shared resource is depleted as each party abuses it for individual gain, ultimately hurting all who share it.

 

Find Us Here

Share This Page

Share on Facebook  Send to your Twitter page  Save to del.ico.us  Save to LinkedIn  Digg this  Stumble this page.  Add to Technorati favorites  Save this page on your Google Home Page 

For more information

Contact Us

info@sei.cmu.edu

412-268-5800